Taxpayers could end up paying the construction cost of privately owned pipelines, refineries, liquefied natural gas export terminals, and power plants under a provision tucked into the bipartisan Senate permitting deal.
Section 1402 of the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA) would let energy developers sue the federal government over permit denials or delays. To win, developers would have to show that the government denied a permit “in bad faith” as part of “a pattern of disparate treatment” against their type of project, or unreasonably delayed it as part of such a pattern. Successful plaintiffs could receive 50% to 100% of the project’s reasonably expected construction cost, on top of economic damages, attorney fees, and litigation costs. The money would come from the Treasury’s Judgment Fund, and the bill text says that payments “shall not be subject to the availability of appropriations.”
If the bill becomes law, it could complicate future efforts to rein in fossil fuels. A future administration that slows approvals for new LNG export terminals or offshore drilling, for example, could have to defend itself in court and risk taxpayer-financed payouts if it lost. And if developers won, they would have to finish building their projects or repay the awards, unless federal interference made completion largely impossible, meaning the payouts could help finance infrastructure that the companies would then own and operate for profit.
The bill text lists 46 types of eligible projects, about half of which involve producing, transporting, or processing fossil fuels. They include oil and gas production, oil and gas pipelines, refineries, LNG terminals, coal and crude oil exports, fossil-fuel power plants, and enhanced oil recovery. Wind, solar, battery storage, nuclear, geothermal, and transmission projects would also qualify.